Print this post

Friday, February 7, 2025

Beshalach: Bitachon and the Media

by Rav Moshe Leib HaCohen Halbershtadt, Founder and Director of YORU Jewish Leadership, yeshiva.org.il, translated by Hillel Fendel.




In honor of this week's Torah portion of Beshalach (Sh'mot 13,17-17,16), let us recount the amazing story of the Splitting of the Red Sea and what followed it. The Children of Israel had lived as a sub-caste, and even as tortured slaves, for hundreds of years – and then suddenly find themselves in the midst of one of the most magnificent chapters in human history. They saw with their own eyes how G-d smacked their Egyptian tormentors with supernatural plagues, one after the next. They also watched how their Egyptian neighbors suffered the plagues, while they themselves, in the same places and at the same time, were untouched. They saw the Egyptians drink blood, while they themselves enjoy pure water; and the same for each plague afterwards. Thus was revealed before their eyes Divine Providence in its full strength and glory, with G-d Himself accompanying them the entire time: "G-d walked before them by day in a pillar of cloud to show them the way, and at night in a pillar of fire for light" (13,21).

But then, suddenly, the story takes an about-turn: The Children of Israel, having left Egypt, abruptly find themselves caught in a deadly trap. The Egyptians were taking chase, and even at the very shoreline the Egyptians keep coming – and the Jews have nowhere to go! They are trapped and begin panicking. What can they do? They begin complaining to their leader Moshe Rabbeinu, as if they had not just been miraculously rescued from bondage: "Are there no graves in Egypt, that you have taken us to die here in the desert? What have you done to us by taking us out of Egypt!?" (14,11)

Moshe calms the nation and encourages them: "Do not fear! Stand and watch G-d's salvation!" (14,13) Moshe raises his arms over the sea, G-d brings a strong wind, and – one of the most astonishing miracles in history happens in front of their eyes! The sea in front of them splits open! Israel goes through dry land and reaches the other side, while the cruel pursuers keep coming and are decimated by the power of the returning waves.

The miracles that Bnei Yisrael were exposed to at this time were so tremendous that our Sages of blessed memory say that the Jews were then on the highest level of prophecy. We are taught that what a simple maidservant saw at the Red Sea at that time was greater than all the prophecies ever seen by the Isaiah and Ezekiel!

From the Red Sea, the Jews traveled towards the Promised Land through the Shur Desert – but something then came up: "They walked for three days in the desert and did not find water. They came to Marah, and [found water] but could not drink it, for it was bitter." (15,22-23) What would be expected now of Bnei Yisrael, now that they have been miraculously saved both in Egypt and at the Red Sea? Would they not probably pray to G-d? They did not: "The nation complained to Moshe…" (15,24) What happened to even a bit of faith and trust in G-d after all they saw and went through? 

G-d is not bothered. He immediately solves the water shortage with another miracle: "G-d showed [Moshe] a tree, he threw it into the water, which then became sweet…" (15,25)

Bnei Yisrael continue to the Sin Desert, and they find themselves without food. They complain yet again, saying they would rather have died in Egypt where they had lots of meat and bread to eat. So strange! Not only do we see a nation without faith, but they have even managed to so quickly forget the tortures they underwent in Egypt!

Yet, once again, G-d performs a miracle for them: "I will rain down for you bread from the heavens…" (16,4).

The next station is Refidim, where another water shortage strikes them. Here already the nation openly revolts: "The nation fought with Moshe and said, Give us water! … They complained to Moshe: 'Why did you raise us up from Egypt to kill us by thirst?' Moshe cried out to G-d, saying: 'What shall I do with this people? They are close to stoning me.'" (17,2-4)

G-d lost no time, and told Moshe, "Strike the boulder, and water will come out of it for the nation to drink." (17,6)

How are we to understand this phenomenon? Bnei Yisrael see and experience so many unprecedented miracles and the hand of G-d before their very eyes, time after time – and yet when something goes wrong, they forget everything! How is it that with every test, they enter a state of hysteria, and instead of trusting Hashem, they fall into a pattern of complaints, and sometimes even worse?

---- ---- ---- ----

I recall during the Persian Gulf War days, I was with my wife in Ashkelon when we beheld a long line of very worried citizens, many of them even in a panic. I asked what was going on, and a man told me, "What, haven't you heard? The U.S. has attacked Iraq again with cruise missiles, and Saddam Hussein threatened to retaliate by attacking Israel! So we all need masking tape to secure our windows, and gas-masks [for those who didn't have]! Scary and dangerous!"

I asked my wife, "I understand that there is a need to prepare for different eventualities, but why such panic? Have they forgotten the great miracles when Iran sent Scud missiles our way, and though 39 of them hit us, in major population centers, only one or two civilians were killed! Why such panic now?"

But the answers are simple: The headlines that morning blared out. "Dozens of U.S. Tomahawk Missiles Landed in Iraq" and "Israel Says, We'll Respond if Attacked," and all the columnists and commentators discussed and debated the dangers and chances from every possible angle. And the immediate result, precisely as expected, was the fears and panic of the media-addicted masses. The powerful influence of the press and its obsessive pre-occupation with doomsday scenarios explain exactly why the masses go into panic-mode.

This insight can help us understand Bnei Yisrael's constant complaints and fears in the desert. It was the fault of "the media" of those times – none other than the erev rav, the Mixed Multitude of stragglers who joined up with the Jewish nation on its way out of Egypt. They were the "commentators" who constantly harped on the dangers and the fearful prospects of what could happen and all the dangers ahead. They explained what would befall babies if there was no water, and the terrible diseases that awaited the elderly if there was no food, and even provided in-depth analyses of the process of death by dehydration. Israel's fears were the natural outgrowth of the erev rav's success in shining their spotlights away from the miracles of the past and directly onto the fears of the future.

However, there were some who did not fall into this trap. They focused on G-d's saving presence in their midst, and concentrated on their trust that G-d would continue to be with them, hand in hand, all the way -  just as he had been until now. Nachmanides explains that when the Israelites jeered Moshe, "Is there a lack of graves in Egypt?" – it is not likely that this was the unanimous opinion: "People who are crying out to be saved are not likely to speak in this manner. Rather, there were different groups, and it was only one of these groups that denied G-d's providence."

We thus learn a great fundamental in the attribute of Trust in G-d, one that is very relevant to today. Every person has the free choice whether to pay careful attention to every peep that comes out of the mouth of a reporter or commentator, and be enchained to it and its resulting frights, and thus to live a life of worry. Alternatively, he can refrain from overly worrying about the future, and rather remember to always look back at the successes of the past, at how Hashem saved us time and again, and to live a life of serenity, faith, and trust in our Father in Heaven. 

May we merit to be of the latter type!

No comments:

Post a Comment