by (abridged) Shalom Vasserteil, CEO Tzipcha International, translated by Hillel Fendel.
We read in this week's Torah portion of Pinchas (Bamidbar 25,10-30,1; outside Israel, Parashat Balak is read) of the "covenant of peace" that G-d gave to Pinchas. This happened after Pinchas zealously killed a public adulterer and thus saved the People of Israel from the punishing plague of death.
What exactly was this "covenant of peace" that G-d gave Pinchas after such an un-peaceful act of public execution? One explanation is that true peace is based not on flattery and false pretenses, but on Torah and ethics. "There is no peace to the wicked ones, said G-d" (Yeshayahu 48,22); by killing Zimri, Pinchas shattered the false peace and alliance between the evil ones – as well as the divisions between Israel and G-d.
But still, why specifically a covenant of "peace" of all things? We know that the attribute truth was very strong in the Israelite tradition up to then – "Give peace to Yaakov," we read; Yaakov was a man of truth, as was Moshe Rabbeinu, who strongly symbolized this attribute. Why peace, therefore, and not truth? These two traits are actually quite different: While Aharon pursued peace and brotherhood, Moshe would say, "Let the law pierce the mountain!"
In fact, the Talmud discusses whether "compromise" is a correct approach – for, after all, it is, by definition, not the truth of the matter. Some sages that it is actually forbidden, while others say that it is the preferred approach. In the Mishnah of Pirkei Avot (1,12), we read support for this latter methodology: "Be of the students of Aharon [grandfather of Pinchas] – lover of peace and pursuer of peace, love people, and bring them close to Torah." The Rambam says that Aharon would speak with sinners, approach them with love, to the point that they would then wish to be like him, correct their ways, and become his students.
When our Sages seek to explain what was the nature of the "covenant of peace" that G-d forged with Pinchas, they generally focus on three aspects. One is the Priesthood itself, as the verse here states: "Pinchas has turned My wrath away from Israel, in that he was zealous for My sake… Behold, I give him My covenant of peace… the covenant of an everlasting priesthood…" Thus, priesthood is peace.
A second approach is that peace here means "protection," in various ways. One aspect is that the covenant will protect from "zealousness." Pinchas, after all, performed a very violent act of spearing two people to death. Yes, it was justified and necessary to stop the plague, but it was liable to imbue within the perpetrator traits of cruelty, anger and violence. The 19th-century R. Naftali Tzvi Yehuda Berlin, author of the Haamek Davar commentary on the Torah, explains that G-d gave Pinchas with this covenant a guarantee that the violent act would not stain his soul; he would rather become a Priest – a man of peace, love and kindness – and this would balance him, cleanse his soul of the remnants of violence, and ensure that what he did would remain a one-time act and not a fixed attribute of his character. Rather, the priesthood would restore him to the way of peace of his grandfather, Aharon HaCohen.
It would even stand him in good stead in next week's Torah portion, where we read that Moshe appointed Pinchas to head the military as it "avenged G-d's vengeance" against the Midianites who coaxed Israel to sin.
At the end of our Shmoneh Esrei prayer, we say Oseh shalom bimromav, "He Who makes Peace above, may He bring peace upon us and upon all Israel." We request that we will know how to balance between the various contradictory forces and elements in our lives, just as G-d did with the four basic elements [earth, wind, fire, water] when He created the world, and thus turn every argument and dispute into a building block of positivity.
This balance brings us to an additional level of this gift of the "covenant of peace" given to Pinchas – a way of life for both the individual and the collective. Regarding the fast of the 17th of Tammuz which occurred this week, as well as the other fasts, the prophet Zechariah says that they will become days of joy and gladness, in which truth and peace will not only coexist, but will do so in love and harmony: "The fast of the fourth month, and the fast of the fifth, and the fast of the seventh, and the fast of the tenth, shall be for the house of Yehuda joy and gladness… therefore love the truth and peace" (8,19). Just as G-d makes peace in His heavens, finding balance between opposites, so the preferred way is to make peace upon us and upon all of Israel.
Truth alone does not suffice; we must walk in the path of peace of Aharon HaCohen, without harming the value of truth – even if it does not remain totally pure. We must go beyond the letter of the law, and even take the path of compromise - the path with which G-d blessed Pinchas.
Both on the individual and communal levels, we cannot run our lives, or a country, based on strict rulings that do not take into account all of the considerations. Israel's Legal Counsel [today, a woman by the name of Gali Bahrav-Miara] is just that: one who does not make decisions, but gives counsel to the government, which then takes this opinion into account as it makes its final decisions. The Legal Counsel is to present a version of the "truth," and the government must see if it can be implemented precisely as is, or whether various elements of "peace" must be sifted in so that the best decision will result. G-d is the "King who loves justice and law," we say in our prayers, and not law alone.
This approach must be adopted, for a prime example, in the controversial matter of the IDF's recruitment of Torah students and the possible overturning of decades of custom in Israel. This would seem to be an additional, profound layer of the gift of the "covenant of peace" given to Pinchas – allowing him to hold the priesthood on one hand, and to lead the army to war against the Midianites on the other. Peace is not merely the absence of war, but primarily harmony and synthesis – a balance between zealotry and the attribute of loving-kindness.
Not for naught does the Shulchan Arukh (O.C. 123,1) rule that when we recite the above-words "He Who makes peace in the Heavens," we should take three steps backwards, and turn to both sides and ask for peace amongst us as well. For in order to reach peace - such as in our family life, in the synagogue, and in the public arena - we must know that despite the truth, it is G-d's will that each side soften up and step a bit backwards. This will enable the necessary peace to "come upon us and all of Israel, and let us say Amen."
No comments:
Post a Comment